I make a point to completely turn off my phone as I step into a theater. Not just on vibrate – all the way off. I mention this not because I'm superior, or to imply that the specter of Billy Wilder will materialize to offer approval. I see it as one of life's little pleasures: for at least ninety minutes, I exist as entirely unreachable. I leave my phone deactivated for the duration of the scroll as well. It feels luxurious to remain seated as the audience trickle away, lit only by the closing titles.
And, lately, by the light of the Letterboxd application.
In excess of millions of users use Letterboxd, a movie-logging platform. In the vein of A24, it has transformed into industry shorthand for a particular kind of aficionado who hypes latest films and finds joy in unearthing old classics. Members score and write about films, and the funniest or most illuminating reviews become popular, incentivizing cinephiles to write diligently.
"Unless I jot down my ideas quickly when the film concludes, my reviews are significantly less clear and eloquent," noted Josh Stern.
In a trip to the cinema, the end titles had just begun before the man ahead of me started composing his thoughts. Not far away, a couple lingered, heads bowed, recording their respective thoughts.
The renowned film-maker David Lynch shared some wisdom: record every great idea the very second it occurs to you. Otherwise, it could be forgotten, and, in his words: "If you forget a good idea, it makes you want to commit suicide." While Lynch spoke to budding directors, this mindset pertains to the act of reviewing.
Josh Stern, a young university attendee in New York, invariably composes his critiques before leaving the auditorium.
"If I don't get my thoughts out immediately when the film concludes, my write-ups are far less coherent and articulate," he said. "The process demands a bit. I'm pretty slow, and my significant other doesn't like it."
He goes to the movies a great deal – 182 times in a single year – and is on a friendly footing with the theater staff, who sometimes have to ask him to leave so they can commence sweeping the theater. He considers it acceptable to take advantage of the end credits: "Upon buying a theater ticket, the credits are part of the film experience."
Letterboxd's most fervent supporters attribute the platform with reviving enthusiasm around a battered film industry, where fewer films are made and unemployment is up. (Letterboxd also boasts the kind of demographics advertisers seek – its largest group of users is aged 18 and 24, with those aged 25 to 35.)
Excitement begets more hype; eagerly anticipated movies witness a flurry of engagement on Letterboxd right after the initial screenings. The most-liked review of a divisive movie – "Emily Brontë died centuries ago yet this version is still the worst thing that has ever befallen her" – has received over 50,000 hearts. A different pop culture movie inspired this juxtaposition to a major artist's documentary: "the Eras Tour documentary discovered deceased."
"It's somewhat a habit," remarked one user, a thirty-three-year-old resident who works in marketing. He also chooses to write reviews throughout the credits. "Processing what you just experienced, as soon as you experienced it, enhances the viewing experience. It helps you grasp the key messages of a film. If it produces a feeling of contentment, that's hardly something you recall the next day."
This user feels most compelled to critique a film if it was very good – or awful. Case in point: he recently watched a star-driven project. "I was actually so appalled by how utterly terrible it was, that I was keen to whip out my phone and award it a half-star rating," he said. (He is a tougher reviewer than other film critics, who awarded the film a higher rating, describing it as "smart and entertaining material.")
Dakota Chester, a twenty-eight-year-old professional who manages social media, watched an acclaimed movie at a cinema on the Upper West Side and remained to draft the write-up ("it received a perfect score"). He has observed more egregious conduct: people pulling out their phones to review the movie they are currently watching. "That irritates me," he commented.
One of the movie industry's longest-running urban legends describes a showing of an 1896 silent short that depicted a train pulling into a station. The medium was in its earliest days and – in line with this debunked rumor – the image of a locomotive heading straight toward the camera terrified the crowd so much that people fled in terror.
A hundred and thirty years later, cinema etiquette remains just as problematic. Apparently, no one understand how to act in public anymore, notably when the lights dim: patrons take pictures of the projection, bring in odorous food, and, as seen during a recent cinematic event, sometimes participate in physical altercations.
Some individuals have resorted to social media to debate the acceptability of using Letterboxd in the credits. When one social media user